Can You Survive on Rice?

Rice is enjoyed by many people all over theshort, people on the Rice Diet don't lose fat; they
world, especially Asians. This makes the "Rice Dietonly lose water.
Report" an attractive way of losing weight."Although this could amount to as much as 10-15
Developed in the late 1930s by Dr. Walterpounds in the first few days, the weight loss is
Kempner, a physician at Duke University, the dietillusory. As soon as a regular diet (containing salt)
is composed of cooked rice, fruit, sugar, and tea.was resumed, the water weight was regained,"
It was so restrictive and was originally meant forYetiv explained.
people with severe kidney disease. In April 1944,Kempner's diet plan soon faded into obscurity in
Kempner told the North Carolina Medical Journalthe late 1940s as drugs to fight high blood
about his popular diet and how it had helped lotspressure became readily available. But it was
of patients.recently resurrected by author Judy Moscovitz, a
The Rice Diet was later used by patients withgraduate of the Rice House in Durham, North
high blood pressure, heart disease, and diabeticCarolina, where she reportedly lost 140 pounds.
retinopathy, a serious complication of diabetes.In her book, Moscovitz encourages the dieter to
Kempner claimed his diet managed to control alleat nothing but fruit and rice for four or five
three conditions.months or longer. You can eat any kind of rice
"Dr. Kempner noted that the patients' bloodprovided it has no salt, spices, herbs or
pressure dropped to normal, andcondiments. The dieter is also warned not to take
electrocardiograms showed their hearts haddairy products due to their fat and cholesterol
returned to normal size and function. Bloodcontent.
vessels in the retinas of the eyes also returned toUnfortunately, Yetiv said subsisting on rice alone is
normal," said Theodore Berland in Consumerfoolhardy and potentially life-threatening because
Guide's "Rating the Diets."this diet is low in iron, calcium, zinc, vitamins B12
Along the way, Kempner and his colleagues foundand D, and protein. What's more, we cannot
that the Rice Diet also helped people lose weight.totally eliminate dairy products from our diet
One patient, the wife of Richard Hughes, thebecause they are a rich source of calcium. The
former governor of New Jersey, was a diabeticleast Moscovitz could have done is to tell readers
who weighed 230 pounds when she came toto use low fat or non-fat dairy products. But you
Duke University. After 19 weeks, Kempner saidwon't find any good advice from this book.
she lost 80 pounds and her blood sugar dropped"I consider the Rice Diet to be one of the worst
to normal levels.diet entries in the past decade. It is a very
At first, doctors were skeptical of Kempner'srestrictive, choreographed diet. It teaches the
results. But they were amazed at the results.overweight patient nothing about the dietary
What makes the Rice Diet work?habits which led to the overweight condition to
In "Popular Nutrition Practices: Sense andbegin with, and therefore, doesn't provide him
Nonsense", Dr. Jack Yetiv said this particular diet iswith the necessary tools to prevent regain of the
very low in sodium. This causes diuresis or theweight," Yetiv concluded.
increased secretion of urine in the kidneys. In