Red Leafed Plants: Evolution in Progress?

Each spring when the colorful mosaic of flowerssustain its metabolism.
comes to a close, red-leafed plants stand out inNumerous studies have shown that anthocyanins
the sea of green. While green- and red-leafedcan effectively “reduce both the frequency
trees, bushes, and flora consist of chloroplasts toand severity of photoinhibition [and] expedite
undertake photosynthesis, the latter utilizephotosynthetic recovery. [For example] in
anthocyanins to provide added benefits and tored-osier dogwood (Cornus stolonifera), a
differentiate themselves. The question is, with the30-minute exposure to strong white light [was
continued ozone depletion that allows harmfulfound to have reduced] the quantum efficiency of
ultraviolet (UV) rays to penetrate the atmospherephotosynthesis by 60% in red leaves [and] by
at greater levels and intensity and subtle changesalmost 100% in acyanic leaves (those without
in sunlight ranging from brightness to the way it isanthocyanins). [Then] when the plants were
refracted due to the continued buildup ofreturned to darkness, the red leaves recovered
emissions and pollutants, is the existence ofto their maximum [photosynthetic] potential
red-leafed plants evidence of evolution inafter… 80 minutes [while] their acyanic
progress? Is a transformation underway in whichcounterparts [still had not fully recovered] after
they will become the dominant type?six hours.”[25]
While these questions cannot be readily answered,Another study involving the Setcreasea purpurea,
it appears that red-leafed plants hold severala plant that can grow well under both extremely
advantages. They absorb green and yellowlow light and high light conditions also illustrated this.
wavelengths (two dominant colors of theWhen Setcreasea purpurea plants were kept in
spectrum), they attract “friendly”low light conditions, they did not synthesize
insects to assist with pollination, they repelanthocyanins. Accordingly their leaves were green.
“hostile” pests that would exploitHowever, when these same plants were exposed
them, and they can tolerate environmental stressto bright light conditions, they defensively
better than green-leafed plants because of theiraccumulated anthocyanins in the epidermal layer
slower metabolism. However, to gain theseof their leaves, transforming the color of their
advantages, red-leafed plants must expendleaves to red. Accordingly, when the epidermal
energy and utilize nutrients to produce thelayer consisting of anthocyanins in the red leaves
pigmentation responsible for their color.was removed, they exhibited a photoinhibitory
Red-leafed plants “are common throughouteffect similar to that experienced by green
all orders of the plant kingdom, from… basalleaves, in which their photosynthetic yield was
liverworts [mosses, ferns, gymnosperms (cycadsreduced by between 2-4 times from that of
or conifers)][1] to the most advancedleaves where anthocyanins were present in their
angiosperms (flowering plants with ovaries). Theyepidermal layer.[26]
[exist] in habitats as diverse as the AntarcticSecond, because of their ability “to absorb
shoreline and the tropical rainforests, are asstrongly in the UV region [of the
abundant in arid deserts as in freshwater lakes,spectrum]” anthocyanins have been proven
and seem equally at home in the light-starvedto protect critical structures from
forest understorey (ground-lower level) as in the“potentially damaging [amounts of] UV-B
sun-drenched canopy (upper level-top).”[2]radiation – red-leafed Coleus varieties [were
While the existence of red leaves is transient infound to have retained] higher photosynthetic
some plants (e.g. deciduous plants that changeefficiencies… than green-leafed
colors in the fall, others that start out with redvarieties” after exposure to UV
hues in the spring), it is permanent in otherradiation.[27] However, anthocyanins’ ability
species. The focus of this article is on the plantsto absorb UV radiation is also a double-edged
with red leaf pigments that exist for the durationsword since if damage occurs, such absorption
of their lives.impairs DNA repair.
The “Red” in LeavesThird, since red-leafed plants have slower rates of
Anthocyanins (mainly cyanidin-3-O-glucoside)[3],photosynthesis and metabolism, they can also
which belong to the flavonoid family are the keythrive well in low-light, high or low temperatures
water-soluble pigment responsible for giving a(anthocyanins “function as antifreeze by
plant its red color. They are synthesized in theprotecting leaves during a frost”[28] and
cytoplasm[4] and reside in the vacuole of leaffrom extreme heat) as well as from drought and
cells. Other contributing pigments or photoreceptordesiccation (severe drying of tissues). For
chemicals that emit “reddish” colorsexample, “New Zealand’s liverworts,
are thiarubrine A, the 3-deoxyanthocyanins, the[a primitive and simple land species] are
betalains, some terpenoids, and certainremarkably resilient to environmental stresses
carotenoids. These pigments too, may performsuch as intense sunlight, high temperatures, UV-B
similar functions and provide similar benefits asradiation, and desiccation.”[29]
anthocyanins.In addition to protecting against harmful lighting,
Based on their properties, anthocyanins absorbUV radiation, temperature extremes, droughts
the green and yellow wavebands of light,and desiccation, anthocyanins have been found to
commonly between 500 and 600 nanometersenhance plant resistance to heavy metal
(nm)[5] (each nonmeter is equal to one billionthcontamination (e.g. mercury) and wounds (e.g. leaf
(10-9) of a meter), making leaves appear red topunctures).
purple as they “reflect the red to blueProtection of Photolabile (Light-Sensitive) Defense
range of the visible spectrum”[6] of light. InCompounds and against Herbivory
addition, flavins absorb blue wavelengths of lightAnthocyanins because of their absorptive qualities
[to some degree], also contributing to aalso play an important role in protecting photolabile
“reddish” color in leaves.[7](light-sensitive) molecules from degradation and
“Interestingly [though], the amount of reddamage caused by exposure to bright light and
light that is reflected from red leavesUV radiation. An example of this is illustrated in
often… correlates [poorly] to anthocyaninthe silver beachweed (Ambrosia chamissonis), a
content; leaf morphology (structure and form)plant that grows in sunny areas and contains large
and the amount and distribution of chlorophyllamounts of thiarubrine A, “a potent
are… stronger determinants of reddefense compound that is toxic to insects,
reflectance.”[8] Although chlorophyll is thebacteria, and fungi.” Without protection
pigment responsible for giving most plants theirfrom two anthocyanic pigments –
green color, an experiment showed that it cancyaniding-3-O-glucose and
play a role in red reflectance. When a transparentcyaniding-3-O-(6’-O-malonylglucoside)
pure chlorophyll solution was created from ground– this plant’s defenses would be
up spinach leaves mixed with acetone to dissolverendered impotent since thiarubrine A is
chloroplasts and their membranes, it reflected aphotolabile; even short exposures to visible light
“reddish glow/flourescence” when aand/or [UV] radiation render it inactive.”[30]
beam of light was directed at it.[9]Second, red color alone has also been found to
When it comes to Rhodophyta (Red Algae),protect plants from herbivory (harmful insects
phycoerythrin, a pigment belonging to theand organisms that feed on them). For example,
phycobilin family found in its chloroplasts is“California maple aphids… readily [and
responsible for its color. Phycoerythrins absorbharmfully] colonize [and exploit] yellow-orange
(between 500 and 650 nm. of)[10] blueleaves of Japanese maples [while ignoring]
wavelengths of light and reflect red wavelengthsred-leafed [Japanese maples]. Similarily, leaf-cutting
as Rhodophyta engage in photosynthesis.ants from tropical forests… browse
Photosynthesissignificantly less on red leaves than on green
Photosynthesis is the process that plants andleaves, [indicative that] athocyanins may serve as
some bacteria use to convert energy fromaposematic signals (warning of a special defense
sunlight into sugar (glucose); which cellularagainst enemies such as poison and toxins),
respiration converts into ATP (adenosine[mimick the appearance of dead, inedible foliage
triphosphate), chemical energy or theand/or] simply render the leaves
“fuel” used by all living organisms.unpalatable.”[31]
Photosynthesis uses six molecules of waterAttraction of “Friendly” Creatures
(transported through the stem from the roots)While serving as a potent repellant to herbivores
and six molecules of carbon dioxide (that enterthat could potentially cause serious or mortal
through a leaf’s stomata or openings) toharm through ingestion of plant foliage and
produce one molecule of sugar (glucose) and sixcompounds, anthocyanins also play the opposite
molecules of oxygen (6H2O + 6CO2 ->role when it comes to “friendly”
C6H12O6+ 6O2), the latter, which is released intocreatures. “The red colors of anthocyanic
the air (also through the leaf’s stomata).leaves”[32] also serve as a means to
Although “sugar (glucose) molecules formedattract “birds, insects and mammals…
during photosynthesis serve as… thefor pollination and reproduction
primary source of food”[11] for plants,[purposes].”[33] When the fruit and
excess sugar (glucose) molecules are convertedbackground foliage of a Canadian shrub were
into starch, “a polymer… to storemanipulated, it was found that “red-orange
energy”[12] for use at a later time when[coloring accentuated] the conspicuousness of [its]
photosynthetic sources of energy are lacking.black-colored fruits to birds [enabling them to
While chlorophyll (green) is the best-knownremove the fruits at a higher rate, accordingly
photosynthetic pigment, other pigments also playenhancing the plants’ reproductive efforts
a role in converting sunlight into useable energy.since when the fruits were consumed, their
They include carotenoids such as caroteneinedible seeds fell to the ground for possible
(orange), xanthophylls (yellow), and phycoerythringermination].[34]
(red). When engaging in photosynthesis, chlorophyllAntioxidants and Scavenging Free Radicals
“absorbs its energy from the Violet-BlueAnother important role of anthocyanins is that
and Reddish orange-Red wavelengths, and littlethey serve as antioxidants to scavenge free
from the intermediate (Green-Yellow-Orange)radicals (highly oxidized compounds that could
wavelengths,”[13] while carotenoids anddamage proteins, membrane lipids, DNA and other
xanthophylls absorb some energy from the greenbotanic structures) for salvageable compounds
wavelength, and phycoerythrin absorbs aand diffuse their harmful energy. They reduce the
significant amount of its energy from the blueamount of oxidized compounds by filtering out
wavelength. Many plants use multiple pigments foryellow-green light since “the majority of
photosynthetic purposes, enabling them toreactive oxygen in plant cells is derived from the
maximize use of sunlight that falls on their leaves.excitation of chlorophyll.”[35] In one study,
When comparing photosynthesis that occursanthocyanins were found “to have the
within red and green leaves, the latter, whichstrongest antioxidizing power of [a group] of 150
have greater concentrations of chloroplasts,flavonoids.” In another study, conducted by
scientific studies have shown that the rate ofthe USDA, anthocyanins in blackberries were
photosynthesis is higher in green-leafed plants. Infound to have a potent antioxidant capacity
one experiment, green and red leaves wereagainst “superoxide radicals, hydrogen
collected from the same deciduous tree andperoxide, and other oxidants.”[36] A third
exposed to 5-10 minutes of light and another 5-10study, involving Arabidopsis plants (a species
minutes of darkness. Afterwards the change inbelonging to the mustard family that have white,
Carbon Dioxide (CO2) levels was measured toyellow or purplish flowers) found that exposure
determine the rate of photosynthesis. The“to strong light and low temperatures
“results showed that green leaves [had] acaused more lipid peroxidation in
higher mean rate of photosynthesis (-.5855 partsanthocyanin-deficient [plants]… Similarly, upon
per million (ppm) CO2/minute/gram) than redgamma irradiation, only those Arabidopsis plants
leaves (-0.200 ppm CO2/minute/gram). [However]that contained both anthocyanin and ascorbic acid
the differences in [the] average rates ofwere able to grow and flower
photosynthesis were not significantlynormally.”[37]
different.”[14]Likewise, in a study involving Elatostema rugosum
Another experiment compared the photoperiodicplants it was “established that red-leaved
sensitivity of green-leafed (Perilla frutescens) andmorphs held a significant antioxidant advantage
red-leafed (Perilla crispa) Perilla (flowering Asianover green morphs.”[38]
annuals) or how long it took each of the PerillaIn addition a study reported by Kevin S. Gould
plants to reach the same level of growth oralso showed that anthocyanins served as a
flowering based on exposure to different lightchemical remedy to repair damage caused by
conditions. When exposed to 8 hours of light,oxidation and free radicals. “Microscopic
red-leafed Perilla took 4 days longer to reach theexaminations of wounded leaf peels have shown
same growth stage as green-leafed Perilla. Thethat red-pigmented cells eliminate Hydrogen
results were more dramatic when each plant wasPeroxide (H2O2) significantly faster than…
exposed to continuous light – red-leafedgreen cells.”[39]
Perilla took between 47 to 55 days longer toConclusion
reach the same growth stage as green-leafedWhile it appears red-leafed plants with their slower
Perilla.[15]metabolic rate (to compensate for the edge
A third experiment involved an in-depth study ofgreen-leafed plants hold regarding photosynthesis)
photosynthesis in red- and green-leafed Quintiniahave an advantage because of the powerful
serrata, a tree native to New Zealand. When thepresence of anthocyanins that give them an edge
rate of photosynthesis was measured at thein hostile environments and assist with healing, the
“cellular, tissue, and whole leaf levels tocase cannot be made that “red” is
understand the role of anthocyanin pigments onbiologically superior to “green.” Many
patterns of light utilization” of red- andgreen-leafed plants also utilize anthocyanins to
green-leafed Quintinia serrata, it was found thatreduce climactic stress – the only difference
“anthocyanins in the mesophyllbeing is that they only expend energy to produce
(photosynthetic tissue between the upper andthis pigment when most needed – spring to
lower epidermis of a leaf) restricted absorption ofresist freezes and in autumn against heightened
green light to the uppermost [section of the]sensitivity to light exposure, thus ensuring that
mesophyll [and that] distribution was furthertheir leaves can “function long enough to
restricted when anthocyanins were also present inunload nutrients and sugars” to store for
the upper epidermis.”[16]the approaching winter and to give them a
Accordingly, “mesophyll cells located“head start for the next growing
beneath a cyanic (blue or bluish) light filterseason.”[40] Last, if advantages of
assumed the characteristic features ofred-leafed plants were materially overwhelming
shade-adapted cells, [with red leaves showing] a(which, if their presence constitutes evolution in
23% reduction in CO2 assimilation underprogress, could some day be the case depending
light-saturating conditions, and a lower threshold ofon global warming, ozone depletion, and other
irradiance (density of radiation occurrence) foradverse ecological changes), the vast majority of
light-saturation, relative to those of greenthe Earth’s land would not be clothed in
leaves.”[17] In short, the findings weregreen.
consistent with the previous two experiments in________________________________
which red leaves displayed slower rates of[1]Kevin S. Gould. Plant ecophysiology research.
photosynthesis, exhibiting photosynthetic(Otago, New Zealand: Department of Botany,
characteristics of “shade-acclimatedUniversity of Otago). 19 May 2006. [
plants.”[18][2]Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
Although green-leaves appear to hold theKnife: The Diverse Protective Role of
advantage when it comes to photosynthesis, thisAnthocyanins in Leaves. Biomedicine and
advantage should not be overstated since toBiotechnology. 15 July 2004. 19 May 2006.
compensate for their slower rate of[3]Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
photosynthesis, red-leafed plants exhibit slowerKnife: The Diverse Protective Role of
metabolism as established by an experiment usingAnthocyanins in Leaves.
Iodine to test for the presence of starch. When I[4]Kevin S. Gould, et. al. Functional role of
tested red leaves of an Acer Palmatum Japaneseanthocyanins in the leaves of Quintinia serrata A.
Maple and Acer Rubrum Red Maple in May 2006Cunn. Journal of Experimental Botany, Vol. 51, No.
(when the leaves were young and after the347 (June 2000). 22 May 2006.
respective trees had expended most of their[5] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
excess reserves over the winter), red IodineKnife…
turned a dark blue when placed on their[6]Anthocyanin. 13 May 2006. 19 May 2006.
sub-epidermal tissue, indicating that each leaf[7]Seeing Red. 29 October 1994. 22 May 2006. [
tested held this polymer. Thus, their[8]Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
photosynthetic activities were not only producingKnife…
sufficient amounts of sugar (glucose) but excess[9]W.P. Armstrong. Photosynthesis & Cellular
reserve amounts. Had the metabolic rate ofRespiration: Supplements To Biology 101 Cell Unit.
red-leafed plants been comparable, the same, or2001. 19 May 2006.
faster than that of green-leafed plants, when their[10]Lecture 5 Photosynthesis I: Light, Pigments,
rate of photosynthesis is slower as established byand Leaves. 22 May 2006. [
the above three experiments, it is unlikely that[11]Karin Tanino. Photosynthesis: Leaf Coloration.
they would have been able to produce excess19 May 2006.
sugar (glucose) as evidenced by the presence of[12]Starch. Polymer Science Learning Center,
starch.Department of Polymer Science, University of
In addition, the presence of anthocyanins, whichSouthern Mississippi. 2003. 22 May 2006.
slow photosynthetic rates also provide an[13]M.J. Farabee. Photosynthesis. 2001. 19 May
advantage. They give red-leafed plants a higher2006. [
tolerance for harmful UV rays, which can reduce[14]Courtney Marne et. al.. The Effects of Leaf
photosynthetic productivity in green-leafed plants.Color on Rates of Photosynthesis. Colorado
This is especially important when considering theUniversity Boulder (Boulder, CO. 2004). 19 May
ongoing depletion of the stratospheric ozone layer2006.
that filters harmful UV rays, minimizing the level[15]William P. Jacobs. Comparison of Photoperiodic
that reaches the earth’s surface.Sensitivity of Green-Leafed and Red-Leafed Perilla.
AnthocyaninsPlant Physiology Vol. 70. July 1982. 19 May 2006.
The presence of anthocyanins provide important[16]Kevin S. Gould et al. Profiles of photosynthesis
benefits (which are discussed below) to red-leafedwithin red and green leaves of Quintinia serrata.
plants. Had their presence been for merePlant Sciences Group, School of Biological Sciences,
extravagance (e.g. solely to provide color –University of Auckland (Auckland, New Zealand:
red, pink, purple, and blue hues to enable theseSeptember 2002). 19 May 2006.
plants to stand out from the sea of green) it is[17]Kevin S. Gould et. al. Profiles of
unlikely that red-leafed plants would makephotosynthesis…
“the considerable metabolic[18]Kevin S. Gould et al. Profiles of
investment” and expend energy tophotosynthesis…
synthesize and accumulate the pigment in their[19] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
leaf cells. As Kevin S. Gould, one of theKnife…
world’s leading botanists and researchers[20] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
wrote, “…a wealth of…Knife…
evidence, ascribes a remarkable diversity of[21]Glenn Rosenholm. Maples gamble on
functions to anthocyanins… many of themantioxidant’s value, says New England
associated with stress responses and someresearcher. News Release USDA Forest Service
potentially critical to a plant’sNortheastern Area. 18 October 2005. 24 May
survival.”[19] In his words,2006.
“Anthocyanins are arguably the most[22] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
versatile of all [plant] pigments, their multifariousKnife…
(diverse) roles in plant stress responses stemming[23]Anthocyanin. 13 May 2006. 19 May 2006.
as much from the physicochemical property of[24] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
light absorption as from their unique combinationKnife…
of biochemical reactivities.”[20][25] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) ForestKnife…
Service Researcher Paul Schaberg, a plant[26]David Dewez et. al. Photorotective role of
physiologist agrees. “There are all kinds ofanthocyanins regulating PSII activity
strategies that [plants] have to protect[27] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
themselves and increase their chance of survival.Knife…
…some trees have deep roots to get extra[28]Glenn Rosenholm. Maples gamble on
water and survive droughts. Others survive byantioxidant’s value, says New England
just using less of the water they get. …redresearcher. [29]Kevin S. Gould. Plant ecophysiology
leaf coloration may be one of those specializedresearch. Department of Botany, University of
adaptive traits…”[21]Otago (Dunedin, New Zealand). 19 May 2006. [
Protection from Hostile Environments[30] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
“When leaves receive more light energyKnife…
than can be used in photochemistry, they show a[31] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
characteristic decline in the quantum efficiency ofKnife…
photosynthesis, termed photoinhibition. Under[32] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
severe conditions [critical leaf structures such asKnife…
chloroplasts, thylakoid membranes (the area
where photons from sunlight initiate[33]Sean Henahan. Time to Leave. The National
photosynthesis), DNA, and proteins essential forHealth Museum. 19 May 2006.
photosynthetic activities can be harmed or[34] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
destroyed].”[22]Knife…
Anthocyanins, through their absorption of[35] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
blue-green light, “have been shown toKnife…
protect plants from excess light during periods of[36]Marilyn Sterling, R.D. Got Anthocyanins?
high light stress (as occurs when plants areNutrition Science News. (Penton Media, Inc. 2006).
exposed to high light in combination with drought19 May 2006. [
or cold temperatures)”[23] by providing a[37] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
physicochemical barrier to protect a leaf’sKnife…
chloroplasts and other critical structures.[38]Samuel O. Neill et. al. Antioxidant capacities of
“Chloroplasts irradiated with light that hasgreen and cyanic leaves in the sun species,
first passed through a red filter have been shownQuintinia serrata. Functional Plant Biology. Abstract.
to generate fewer superoxide radicals (highly19 May 2006.
oxidized compounds)” that could damage a[39] Kevin S. Gould. Nature’s Swiss Army
plant’s “photosystems (group ofKnife…
structures that perform[40]Glenn Rosenholm. Maples gamble on
photosynthesis)”[24] and impair its ability toantioxidant’s value, says New England
transfer and use necessary sugar (glucose) toresearcher.